Ayako Wakao

Kyôko Kishida

Eiji Funakoshi

Jun&apos;ichirô Tanizaki

Kaneto Shindô

A childless housewife falls in love with a beautiful model.

Yasuzô Masumura

Manji

&quot;We told you this was melodrama&quot;

By 1964 standards, this film really doesn&apos;t mess around, nor does it take any prisoners. It&apos;s fairly blatant about the story centering on two women who fall in love, but also don&apos;t entirely cut their husbands/male partners out of their lives, which leads to complications and some drastic things that feel a little extreme, but I&apos;d chalk it up to Japan being a different culture at a different time... or just the film trying to make a point, and not necessarily be a reflection of how this situation would play out in real life. Have to accept it&apos;s one or the other; I think you just have to admit defeat, in a way, by saying you don&apos;t always know for sure when it comes to foreign films.

The dark and emotionally intense places Manji goes also make it feel a bit melodramatic, but again, I can&apos;t assume. And even then, if it is melodrama, I think it&apos;s mostly well-done melodrama; that kind of thing isn&apos;t automatically bad. Maybe there&apos;s some repetition and characters saying things in such a blatant way that can feel forced, but it could be partly intended. Perhaps it&apos;s wrong to assume it either is or isn&apos;t clunky dialogue. The truth could be somewhere in between.

Waffling here. It&apos;s not well-paced, but the film is well-acted and I admire how it handled such a story 60 years ago. If some of the melodrama was intended, then I think the writing was acceptably blunt and the performances were effectively heightened. The grimmer parts of the story don&apos;t quite devastate the way I thought they would, but that might be owing to the film&apos;s structure, with one character narrating a series of events from her perspective. It creates some intrigue, but also some sense of inevitability; a bit of a double-edged sword. And then it also ends pretty suddenly.

But I have to keep coming back to it being good for its time. I wasn&apos;t expecting this film to take the approach it did, and I imagine it would&apos;ve caused at least some controversy in Japan at the time.

By 1964 standards, this film really doesn't mess around, nor does it take any prisoners. It's fairly blatant about the story centering on two women who fall in love, but also don't entirely cut their husbands/male partners out of their lives, which leads to complications and some drastic things that feel a little extreme, but I'd chalk it up to Japan being a different culture at a different time... or just the film trying to make a point, and not necessarily be a reflection of how this situation would play out in real life. Have to accept it's one or the other; I think you just have to admit defeat, in a way, by saying you don't always know for sure when it comes to foreign films.

The dark and emotionally intense places Manji goes also make it feel a bit melodramatic, but again, I can't assume. And even then, if it is melodrama, I think it's mostly well-done melodrama; that kind of thing isn't automatically bad. Maybe there's some repetition and characters saying things in such a blatant way that can feel forced, but it could be partly intended. Perhaps it's wrong to assume it either is or isn't clunky dialogue. The truth could be somewhere in between.

Waffling here. It's not well-paced, but the film is well-acted and I admire how it handled such a story 60 years ago. If some of the melodrama was intended, then I think the writing was acceptably blunt and the performances were effectively heightened. The grimmer parts of the story don't quite devastate the way I thought they would, but that might be owing to the film's structure, with one character narrating a series of events from her perspective. It creates some intrigue, but also some sense of inevitability; a bit of a double-edged sword. And then it also ends pretty suddenly.

But I have to keep coming back to it being good for its time. I wasn't expecting this film to take the approach it did, and I imagine it would've caused at least some controversy in Japan at the time.

bappamtv

Manji

🎭 Top Cast

🎬 Technical Specs

🏷️ Keywords

🎯 Categories

⭐ Featured Review

🎬 More Like This

📖 Synopsis