Two Families

2019TV Episode⏱️ 1h 25mTV-14

DocumentaryCrimeDrama

⭐ 7.9

IMDB Rating

46 votes

April and Michael Holton live a perfect life, until a shocking murder exposes a dark secret. In a 2-hour special with exclusive access, American Monster confronts a terrible choice. If both suspects are your own blood, how do you ...

Director

N/A

Writers

N/A

Stars

Chad Ashworth, Martha Brown, Tonya Caudle

Release Date

September 8, 2019

💬 1

Reviews

📽️ View on IMDB

🎭 Top Cast

👤

Chad Ashworth

as Self - Michael's Brother

👤

Martha Brown

as Self - April's Aunt

👤

Tonya Caudle

as Self - April's Friend

👤

Bill Franklin

as Self - Sheriff Elmore County Sheriff's Dept

👤

April Holton

as Self

👤

Madison Holton

as Self

👤

Michael Holton

as Self

👤

Randall Houston

as Self - Elmore County DA

Daniel Lasker

as Madison Holton

Dominique Maher

as Tonya Caudle

🎬 Technical Specs

Production

Arrow International Media, Arrow International Post Production, Arrow Media

🎯 Categories

CrimeDocumentaryDrama

⭐ Featured Review

A real mystery

by Calicodreamin • 2026-01-05

5/10

"This documentary covers an interesting true crime story that in all likelihood will never be definitively solved. Though this episode definitely did not need to be an hour and a half long. A lot of the content was just the family going back and forth on what they think happened. Good content was few and far between...."

📖 Synopsis

April and Michael Holton live a perfect life, until a shocking murder exposes a dark secret. In a 2-hour special with exclusive access, American Monster confronts a terrible choice. If both suspects are your own blood, how do you ...